Sheila Carter

Sheila Carter
	Kimberlin Brown as Sheila Carter
The Bold and the Beautiful ; The Young and the Restless
Portrayed by	Kimberlin Brown
Current status	Present, Contract
Duration	1992-1998, 2002-2003, 2017-2018, 2021-
First appearance	May 8, 1992
Created by	William J. Bell
Introduced by	Bradley Bell
Profile
Family	Carter family ; Warwick family ; Marone family ; Fisher family ; Finnegan family
Other names	{{{othernames}}}
Gender	Female
Occupation	Nurse for Forrester Creations ; Executive Assistant to Brooke Logan ; Waitress at Il Giardino
Residence	Los Angeles, California
	Michelle Stafford as Sheila Carter, after Sheila had a plastic surgery to look like Phyllis Summers.
Relationships
Parents	Gregory Carter (father) Molly Carter (mother)
Siblings	Sarah Smythe (sister; deceased)
Spouses	Scott Grainger (1991-1993) ; Eric Forrester (1993-1995) ; James Warwick (1997-1998)
Romances	Connor Davis ; Mike Guthrie ; Grant Chambers ; Massimo Marone ; Tom Fisher ; Jack Finnegan ; Deacon Sharpe ; Bill Spencer Jr. (deceived)
Children	Mary Warwick (daughter with James) ; Diana Carter (daughter with Massimo) ; Ryder Callahan (son with Tom) ; Daisy Carter (daughter with Tom) ; John Finnegan (son with Jack)
Grandchildren	Lucy Romalotti (granddaughter, via Daisy) ; Hayes Finnegan (grandson, via Finn)

Sheila Carter (formerly Grainger, Forrester And Warwick) is a character from The Young and the Restless and The Bold and the Beautiful.

The role was portrayed by Kimberlin Brown for many intervals on both soaps starting in 1990 until 2006, when the character had plastic surgery to look like Phyllis Summers, and was portrayed by Michelle Stafford. However, the surgery was miraculously reversed, and Sheila went to her original appearance, and the character returned to recurring status on The Bold and the Beautiful on June 9, 2017 and went off-screen in early 2018.

In the week of August 2, 2021 a mysterious woman sees the wedding announcement of Steffy Forrester Finnegan and Finn Finnegan online. Eventually, it's Sheila crashing their wedding at the Forrester Mansion with the exploding news she's Finn's biological mother in the episode of August 6, 2021.

Sheila is known as a villain and is considered to be one of the most well-known and popular daytime soap opera villains on TV. A significant portion of Sheila's history on both soaps revolves around her long-running conflict with Lauren Fenmore, whom she had attempted to kill on multiple occasions. She also had conflicts/catfights with Molly Carter, Judy Johnson, Maria Martinez, Stephanie Douglas, Ruthanne Owens, Sally Spectra, Macy Alexander, Maggie Forrester, Amber Moore, Taylor Hamilton, Brooke Logan, Mary Warwick, Jackie Payne, Maggie Sullivan, Phyllis Summers, Katie Logan, Quinn Fuller, Pamela Douglas, Steffy Forrester and Li Finnegan.

Storylines[]

The Young and the Restless (1990 – 1992)[]

on Y&R.

B&B (1992 – 1998)[]

In 1992, Sheila is reintroduced on The Bold and the Beautiful and she quickly worms her way into fashion CEO Eric Forrester life by becoming the company nurse at Forrester Creations in Los Angeles, as well as working as Rick Forrester's nanny (after staging an accident that leaves the former nanny, Judy Johnson, hospitalized, and later threatening Judy and her family). Sheila and Eric fall in love and are eventually engaged, which angers Eric's ex-wife , Stephanie Douglas, who suspects Sheila is a gold digger and a liar. To Sheila's dismay, Eric's most recent ex-wife, Brooke Logan, is pregnant with a child that may either belong to Eric or his son, Ridge Forrester. After Bridget Forrester is born, Sheila manipulates the paternity test so that everyone will believe Ridge is the father. Security guard Mike Guthrie catches her in the act and after threatening to blackmail her, Sheila sets loose a vicious dog to attack him.

Meanwhile, Lauren finds out that Sheila is alive and well, and living on the West Coast. Lauren follows her and they once again fight. Lauren threatens to expose Sheila to the Forrester family, but Sheila turns the tables on Lauren by blackmailing her with pictures she took of Lauren sleeping with Brad Carlton and sent to Lauren as puzzle pieces. Despite Sheila's love for Eric, she panics when Lauren attempts to disclose her past at the wedding, and leaves a heartbroken Eric at the altar. After the guests leave, Sheila returns to the chapel and pleads for Eric's forgiveness. Although Eric demands answers, he eventually forgives Sheila and the two are married, and she becomes Sheila Carter Forrester. Sheila and Brooke become close friends. Sheila and Eric's marriage becomes rocky when Sheila accepts a job from Brooke, who seizes control of Forrester Creations with her patent on the BeLieF formula. Eric feels betrayed by her actions and a rift is created in their marriage. Sheila proposes the two take a vacation and use this time to reconnect. The two leave town for Catalina Island. Scott, who became ill, also vacations with Lauren in Catalina Island, where the two run into Eric and Sheila. Lauren intends to use Scott to expose Sheila's past to Eric; however, Scott, still caring for Sheila, keeps mum. Scott eventually dies on the island as a result of his illness. With both women by his side, he wishes that Lauren give Sheila a second chance. Lauren tearfully agrees.

When Sheila becomes concerned that Eric is excluding her from his will, she decides she would be more financially secure if she gave Eric a child. After a one-night stand with former rival Connor Davis, Sheila goes to Eric claiming she is pregnant with his child. Eric, who had recently had a vasectomy, tells Sheila he wants a divorce. For some time she begins to see psychiatrist Jay Garvin, who is friends with Brooke's fiancé, Dr. James Warwick. James suspects Sheila is hiding something from the family, and tries to pry information from Dr. Garvin. However, during a brief struggle, Sheila accidentally pushes Jay off a balcony and to his death. James later learns from Lauren the secrets of her past. After attempting to drown Lauren in a hot tub, Sheila kidnaps James with the help of her new partner-in-crime, the security guard Mike. She imprisons him in the basement of her house (known as "The Houdini House") for some time. When James escapes and her secrets finally surface, she holds Stephanie, Eric, Ridge, Brooke, Lauren and James hostage in the Forrester mansion, welcoming them to her "goodbye party."

At the "party," Sheila tells everyone in attendance how they had personally wronged her, and threatens to kill them. Holding a gun to Stephanie, Sheila has a change of heart when the others step in front of her, and swallows a bottle of poison. Having survived, Sheila is placed in a psychiatric hospital, under the care of Dr. Brian Carey, but does not remain there for long, despite Stephanie's attempts to keep her there. Sheila tries to revive her friendship with Brooke, who sides with her at first, but later wants nothing to do with her. She begins dating neighbor Grant Chambers, and later her psychiatrist, James Warwick. She continues to see James at this time, and memories of her abusive childhood are revealed. Sheila confesses that she murdered her father by poisoning him.

Sheila meets Maggie Forrester, whom she befriends. The two are amazed to discover they both have ties to the same family. When Stephanie attempts to take Brooke's children, however, Sheila poisons her by replacing her medication with mercury pills, and ultimately frames Maggie for the crime. Maggie, later realizing who was behind the poisoning, fights with Sheila and accidentally pushes her onto a fire poker, impaling her. Sheila also makes an enemy of Forrester Creations' rival, Sally Spectra who defends Stephanie to her, thus planting the seeds of the eventual friendship between Stephanie and Sally. After the fire poker incident, Sheila sets her sights on proving to James that she has changed for the better, in the hopes that he will fall in love with her. However, James has feelings for Maggie instead. Maggie goes to Sheila's house to inform her that she needs to find a new therapist, because Maggie wouldn't allow her to see James anymore. As Maggie taunts her, Sheila snaps and nearly chokes Maggie to death. Mike later kidnaps her and holds her prisoner at an amusement park. Sheila, wanting to prove to James that she had changed, agrees to release Maggie.

After having crashed James and Maggie's wedding, Sheila reveals that she has become pregnant after a night alone with James. The three come to a settlement that Sheila would temporarily stay with them until her baby was born, and the child would be given to James and Maggie. After Sheila hands her baby, Mary, over to the Warwick's, she relocates to Death Valley, where she meets Amber Moore. Anxious to see her daughter, Sheila suggests that Amber babysit for James and Maggie, so that she can secretly visit Mary in LA. Amber is hired and keeps her alliance with Sheila secret for some time, but when Sheila threatens her, she exposes herself to James and Maggie. Sheila eventually takes matters into her own hands and takes Mary back. James attempts to trick Sheila into marrying him, so that he can gain full custody of his daughter. When Sheila realizes the marriage is a set-up, she attempts to kill herself again by jumping off a roof. James, who had actually fallen for Sheila during this time, promises to stay with her. Meanwhile, an angry Maggie sneaks into Sheila's hospital room and cuts off her oxygen. Sheila is rescued by doctors and Maggie is immediately arrested. With the help of Mike and his brother Martin, a desperate Maggie captures Sheila and holds her prisoner, appropriately, in the house from Psycho at Universal Studios Hollywood. When Sheila escapes, James demands that Maggie leave. Maggie and Lauren later team up in an attempt to drive Sheila over the edge. They wire Sheila's house with hidden cameras and an audio system, while the former nanny Judy surprises Sheila on her doorstep. The plan fails, however, and Maggie, realizing James and the baby are lost to her, leaves town. When a friendship begins between James and Stephanie, a paranoid Sheila becomes jealous and attempts to drown Stephanie in a pool. To prevent Stephanie from telling anyone about this incident, Sheila threatens to kill Stephanie's grandson, Thomas. Sheila is arrested for the threat, but secretly switches places with a woman named Sybil. After breaking out of prison in disguise, Sheila shoots Stephanie, kidnaps baby Mary and leaves town.

Return to L.A. (2002 – 2004)[]

Sheila returns to L.A. four years later to find her now-teenage daughter Mary (whom she had renamed Erica Lovejoy). Erica, who is completely unaware of her mother's past or her own real name, has traveled to L.A. to meet her idol - Amber Forrester. She soon develops a crush on Amber's husband, Rick, although she never intends to act on her feelings. Sheila convinces Erica to seduce Rick, saying that a Forrester man would never abandon the woman carrying his child. She then pays off a man named Lance to drug Amber and take her to bed. Amber tracks Lance down and begins to question him. When a nervous Lance threatens to tell Amber everything, Sheila kills him by releasing a tank of bees into his apartment. Amber becomes increasingly suspicious and confronts Erica in Rick's office. During a struggle, Erica falls and hits her head on a desk, making Amber look guilty of pushing her. At the hospital, a disguised Sheila confronts Amber, warning her to stay away from her daughter. Amber decides to look for clues at Erica's apartment, but is impeded when Sheila throws a pot at the window and the police arrive, arresting Amber and causing the Forresters to distrust her further. Meanwhile, while browsing through a photo album of Eric's, Erica is startled to find a picture of her mother. She learns that Sheila was formerly married to Eric, and that her mother wants her to live the life she had always dreamed of with Rick. Sheila pushes Erica to have sex with Rick, so that she can live vicariously as a Forrester through her daughter.

As a reluctant Erica is about to carry out her mother's plan, Rick's brother Ridge bursts in and exposes Erica's true identity. Rick kicks Erica out, but not before Sheila kidnaps Amber, who is stunned to learn that Erica is really Mary Warwick. Sheila stages a crime scene and drags Amber off to her apartment. Massimo Marone, who had been romantically involved with Sheila for a short time, gets a call from her, and Stephanie recognizes her voice. The two track Sheila and Amber down. Sheila then flees and holds Eric and Taylor Hayes hostage at the mansion. But when Brooke walks into the room, a struggle ensues in which Taylor and Brooke are shot. Brooke survives her wounds, whereas Taylor succumbs (a few years later, Taylor was revealed to still be alive). Sheila is arrested and subsequently confronted by her daughter, who condemns Sheila's actions and wants nothing to do with her. Sheila is jailed for her crimes but soon escapes with the help of a sympathetic warden named Sugar.

She then kidnaps Ridge and Brooke, while on their South American honeymoon. Soon Ridge's half-brother Nick Marone arrives to rescue Ridge but he is soon captured by Sheila as well. When Ridge and Nick's father, Massimo, arrives to deliver the ransom, Sheila reveals that she had a baby daughter, Diana, whom she claims to be the result of the fling she had with Massimo during her previous trip to L.A. When Massimo tries (unsuccessfully) to trick Sheila into handing over the infant, she and Sugar run away. Brooke and Nick are soon rescued; however, it is believed that Ridge had been burned to death in the foundry Sheila stashed him in. Soon after, it is revealed that Ridge had survived, and he reunites with Brooke on the island.

Return to Y&R (2005 – 2007)[]

Y&R return.

Second return to L.A. (2017 - 2018)[]

Sheila returns to Los Angeles on June 9. When she attempts to leave Katie Logan's home without being noticed, Quinn Fuller hears her leaving, immediately asking who she is. She tells Quinn she is Sheila, an old friend of the Logans. Quinn dismisses this as she had never heard of her, but then told this to Eric Forrester at home, who asked if it was Sheila Carter - his ex-wife. If so, Eric warned Quinn to stay well away, as Sheila is trouble.

Coming home after being interrogated about the attempted murder of Quinn, Katie finds Sheila in her home. She is immediately frightened and threatens to call the police, but Sheila assures her that she is a changed woman after serving time, and that she should put in some good word for her within the Forresters. Katie messages Eric without Sheila seeing, to which Eric rushes to the scene, questions Sheila's intentions (to which he got the same answers), and proceeds to call Lt. Bradley Baker, claiming to have found the shooter. Sheila was taken into custody.

Sheila is interrogated at the police station, and pleads to have known nothing of a shooting. She tries to convince Baker and Eric of her innocence, and the same lines of how her involvement with the Forresters (and the time she had served) has changed her for the better. However, given her track record, and the fact that she had already violated a restraining order from Eric, Sheila was arrested and taken away.

It turns out Sheila was, however, telling the truth. Shots were fired again at Quinn while Sheila was away. Quinn sees them and rushes inside, and hides. Enter a seemingly drunken Deacon Sharpe, whom had arrived after a long disappearance. Quinn tells him to hide, but Deacon reassures her and says that he can deal with them. He calls 911. Quinn thanks him, but Deacon, going for Eric's tequila, goes off at Quinn as to how she can get everything she wants - and leaving him with nothing. He reverts back to being shoved off a cliff, then saving Quinn and housing her, and then her mistreating him and finding solace with Eric. Quinn and Deacon spar and argue for a period, but Quinn is mainly focused on her safety. She asks Deacon to see his phone and check how long it had been since the police called. Deacon reaches into his pocket and grabs a pistol, saying that they both know he faked that call.

Deacon continues his ranting at Quinn while holstering his gun at her, saying that he was the one shooting her, as she deserves not to live knowing she had mistreated him. Quinn fears further for her life, but Katie finds Quinn in this situation while spying from afar with her telescope. Katie calls Ridge Forrester, whom had been called to Quinn's guard since the shooting first occurred. Ridge rushes to the scene right in the nick of time, knocks Deacon unconscious and grabs the gun. He then goes to comfort Quinn, as her hero.

Deacon wakes up after Ridge had called the police. Deacon remembers nothing of the incident, however, was told all about it. Deacon explained he is even broker than before and had reverted back to alcoholism. Deacon asked Quinn for money, a place to live, and, preferably, his life back. Quinn said that Deacon tried to kill her, refusing to, before the police and Eric arrive to take him away.

Brooke Logan, Bill Spencer Jr. and Wyatt Spencer were called for comfort and further concern, and Katie came to explain it was her that called Ridge, to which Quinn was grateful. She then proceeded to walk outside, knowing the shooter was gone. Eric got a call from Lt. Baker, saying that Deacon was in the process of being booked, and that Sheila was innocent - however, she had broken the restraining order. Eric had the choice whether or not to continue with the charges, to which he decided not to.

Quinn goes out on the porch again, and Ridge follows. They talk, and Quinn thanks him for protecting her. She then tells him she is falling in love with him, to which he answers back. They share a passionate moment.

Eric decided to forgive this and overcome past transgressions, as there is a level of proof that Sheila had indeed changed. He then proceeds to invite Sheila into the mansion, to a crowd of shock and surprise.

However, Sheila kept plotting to get Eric back and had a portrait of her made and got into fights with Quinn. She also made James to convince Eric to let her stay a little longer, but Quinn didn't buy it. She also plotted to have Mateo seduce Quinn. But he felt guilty about what he did and told Eric. And together he, Eric and Quinn hatched a scheme to lure Sheila. Sheila brought her portrait to hang on Eric's fireplace and thought she finally won. But she soon realized she was fooled as Eric and Quinn were still together. Sheila tried to explain her actions, but Eric didn't buy into her lies, realizing she was still the same person and was never gonna change. As she left, Quinn told her to never come back. But Sheila only laughed menacingly behind a closed door.

Revealing she is Finn's mother (2021)[]

Sheila came back to town to reveal she's John Finnegan's birth mother after seeing the news about his and Steffy Forrester's upcoming wedding. She starts blackmailing Jack Finnegan, who once had a romance with Sheila but kept this quiet for his wife so Jack agrees to her request and gives him Finn's and Steffy's address. Sheila tells him that it will be the first and last time she will see her son and grandson before she will leave LA. Steffy, who was supposed to be a business trip comes home and is furious with Jack and Finn for letting her into her home and allowing her to hold Hayes. Later Sheila visits Finn again and when she sees that he is on Steffy's side and wants her out of the house she pretends that she passed out. Steffy tells her husband that she is faking. Steffy's suspicions were confirmed by Sheila's blood work that revealed no sign of illness. A conversation between Sheila and Deacon she tells him that her other children don't want anything to do with her as the reason why she's so focused on Finn. She convinced Deacon to pretend that she is his girlfriend in front of Finn and Deacon's daughter, but that scheme didn't work and had no good effect so Deacon decided to stop it soon after. She also wanted to sleep with Deacon, but he refused and told her that he has feelings for Brooke. One day Sheila met Brooke at Deacon's work. Brooke told her that she will make sure to keep her away from Steffy, Finn and Hayes. This pushed Sheila over the edge, especially because few days earlier Steffy Forrester and Finn Finnegan invited Sheila the first time so she could celebrate Christmas with them. Sheila decided to punish Brooke and exchanged Brooke's non alcoholic beverage with the real thing knowing that Brooke struggled with alcoholism in the past.

Accidental shooting of her son Finn & attempted murder of Steffy Forrester (2022)[]

Thomas becomes suspicious because of Sheila's behavior and she ends up confessing to him what she did to Brooke because she couldn't help herself and gloated about it and told Thomas that he should thank her for his parents' reunion. She threatens him to keep her secret. They have several more conversations with Sheila threatening Thomas to keep his mouth shut. Finally, Steffy overhears a conversation & then follows him to try to find out what's going on. She sees him in the alley behind where Deacon works having an intense conversation but she can't make out what they are saying. She finally leaves and goes home and tells Finn that his biological mother, Sheila is up to something with her brother, Thomas. After talking to him about it, the next morning, she tells him that she's going to the office and she will get the truth out of Thomas but when she gets there, he's on the phone with someone and quickly figures out that it's Sheila and he ends up unknowingly telling her everything about what Sheila did. After hearing this, she leaves without even confronting Thomas over what she has heard. She goes to confront Sheila with what she has learned. After arguing briefly in the restaurant, they leave and go into the back alley where Thomas was with her before. They get into an argument and Sheila tells her to keep her mouth shut and Steffy tells her that she's telling everyone what she's done. After arguing for sometime and Steffy telling her once again that she's telling everyone what she did and she starts heading for the door, Sheila pulls out a gun from her purse and points it at Steffy. Meanwhile, while they are fighting, Finn is trying to call Steffy to see if she's okay and can't get a hold of her, finally he pings her phone and sees that she is at the restaurant where Deacon works and where she had told them that Thomas and Sheila were arguing. He leaves work and rushes over to the restaurant. When he gets there, he comes into the alley just in time when his mother pulls out a gun and points it at Steffy. She pulls the trigger and when he jumps in front of Steffy, trying to protect her, she shoots him in the stomach. Steffy starts screaming Finn's name and he tells her that he loves her and Hayes and closes his eyes. Steffy goes to call 911 but Sheila points the gun at her again and tells her to put down the phone, she tells her she's going back to prison and this time for life and before she can push the last 1 to call 911, Sheila shoots her point blank in the chest. Then she starts thinking about covering her tracks and steals their rings, wallets, and a few other things.

She returns to her hotel room and showers and then starts talking to herself and crying. After a while, Deacon shows up at her door and breaks it to her that Finn is dead. She starts crying and lays down on her bed and Deacon puts his hand on her back to comfort her. Deacon told a shocked Sheila that Steffy survived so she went to the hospital and pretended to be concerned for her in front of Steffy's family but she was secretly hoping that Steffy wouldn't make it. While she was at the hospital, she had vivid memories of how she shot Finn and Steffy and she decided to take her own life by jumping off the roof. Taylor Hayes stopped her from doing it, but almost fell herself. Sheila saved her life and Taylor embraced her and expressed her gratitude. Taylor said that now she is one of them and told her that Hayes needs her grandma. While Taylor wanted to give Sheila a chance, Ridge remained hostile towards her. When Steffy woke up from her coma, she had amnesia and didn't even remember Finn or Hayes, but instead believed that she is still married to Liam Spencer who really was Hope Logan's husband. Sheila was afraid that Steffy would remember and contemplated whether or not she should finish her off when she got a chance.

Aftermath of Steffy and Finn's shooting (2022)[]

Sheila continues to worry that Steffy will wake up and remember what happened and she doesn't want to go to jail, so she decides that Steffy has to die. She starts to do it when Taylor comes in but she wasn't able to finish Steffy off. She goes into the room when everyone decides to tell Steffy about Finn and begins to worry again and then after she remembers, she thanks Steffy for not kicking her out of the room. But after everyone leaves the room and is talking to her doctor, Bridget, she overhears them talking about managing Steffy's pain so she doesn't get hooked on drugs again. Sheila sneaks back into Steffy's room and contemplates between killing her or getting her hooked on drugs again, either one will solve her problem she says to herself. Liam catches her in Steffy's room and gets suspicious of what she is doing in her room.

After Steffy was released and she went home, Sheila comes by wanting to see her grandson. Steffy gets upset. Taylor let Sheila in after she begged her to let her talk to Steffy about seeing her grandson Hayes. While she & Steffy are talking, she starts having flashes about the night Sheila tried to kill Steffy & Finn, unbeknownst to Sheila. After she left, Steffy remembered everything and she recalled what happened that night in the alley and that is was Sheila who shot her & Finn, also unbeknownst to Sheila. Steffy has Taylor to call Sheila and tell her that she can come over to see her grandson, Hayes. Sheila was with Deacon at the time of the call, telling him she was going to leave town but of course she's elated when Taylor calls her to tell her that she can come see her grandson but what really happened was a setup orchestrated by Steffy in order to lure Sheila to her house and to get her to confess that she shot her & her son Finn. The plan worked and Sheila was arrested. Afterwards, Ridge went to Brooke's house and told her that it was Sheila that caused her to drink on New Year's Eve and that she was also the one who shot Steffy and Finn. After being told this, Brooke went to visit Sheila in jail to tell her what she thought of her. A few days later, Li pays her a visit as well to tell her how evil she is. Finn ends up surviving the gunshot wound,

Sheila requested to see Finn. Initially he was cold towards her, but when she forced a hug suddenly tears begun to swell up into his eyes and he hugged her back. Finn admitted that when she held him he felt something that he missed his whole life. Not long after Finn and Steffy went to court for Sheila's sentencing. They were absolutely sure that Sheila will spend her life in jail. When Finn saw that Liam showed up in the court he was annoyed and reminded Liam that it's a family matter. Liam assured that he is there because the case also matters to him as he is Kelly's father and he cared for the safety of his child. Everyone was shocked when the judge said that the evidence against Sheila Carter wasn't legal and she's free to go. At the corridor Sheila and Finn saw each other and shared another hug. Liam spotted it and recorded the hug. When Liam showed it to Steffy she was shocked, but she decided to trust her husband and didn't tell Finn that she knows anything about it. Liam tried to put doubt into Steffy and continued to nag her about Finn not being trustworthy around their daughter Kelly. At the time Finn and Kelly were at the beach and Sheila was looking at them from a far. Finn got a phone call from work and he asked Kelly to stay in one place. When he turned around Kelly decided to go into the ocean and she started drowning. Sheila saw it and she ran to rescue her. Finn was shocked when he saw his bio mom taking Kelly out of the water. Kelly learned that Sheila is Finn's mother. Finn thanked Sheila for saving Kelly's life. Steffy is outraged.

Stabbing death as a result of self defense by Steffy Forrester Finnegan (2024)[]

After Steffy’s daughter Kelly takes a selfie with her smartwatch and sends it to Steffy, Steffy overreacts seeing Sheila in the background of the photo and frantically calls Lucy who is babysitting. Lucy informs Steffy that Sheila came up and physically spoke to Kelly and asked her if she remembered her. Steffy proceeded to Sheila’s home to confront her about the incident. Sheila defends herself by insisting she had no control over Steffy’s daughter being brought by Lucy to Il Giardino where Sheila works. The confrontation escalates and Sheila shoves Steffy to which Steffy responds by punching Sheila. The confrontation is soon broken up by Finn and Deacon. Finn and Steffy leave and Deacon tries to calm Sheila. Deacon, after seemingly convincing Sheila not to react to the situation; leaves to return to the restaurant. Sheila insists to him that she won’t go after Steffy. However, Sheila throws over the dining table and leaves anyway. She is later seen standing outside of Steffy and Finn’s residence while Steffy is home alone and Finn is away at the office. Sheila utters to herself “Tonight you die.” in reference to Steffy with intent to kill her. A brewing storm knocks the power out at Steffy’s residence and she calls Finn to ask him to come home. Sheila then enters the residence while Steffy is looking for candles in the dark. Steffy sees a shadow lurking on the wall in the moonlight. She turns around and is confronted by a veiled and hooded Sheila. She assumes it’s Sheila and tells her to leave while backing away, falling over the sofa. Steffy quickly then runs to the kitchen and grabs a knife she was using prior to prepare food. Sheila continues to approach Steffy despite her threats of defending herself with the knife and lunges towards her; to which Steffy proceeds to stab Sheila. Steffy then calls the police and Sheila is soon after pronounced dead. Finn returns as the police are leaving to find Steffy alone and distraught. She informs Finn that Sheila is dead and that it was her who killed her in self defense. Finn begins having a hard time coping with Sheila’s death, taking offense when Ridge refers to Sheila as an animal. Stating “That animal was my Mother.” Finn kneels down and places his hand in Sheila’s blood. He says Sheila’s “blood is on my hand, and on yours Steffy.” After her memorial service in April 2024 which was Deacon set up with only Finn, Hope and himself in attendance, she was being cremated when the sheet fell off of her feet as she plunged in the fire, Deacon saw that she had 10 toes instead of 9.

Crimes Committed[]

Drugged and seduced Dr. Scott Grainger (1990).
Stole Lauren Fenmore's newborn son (Scotty Grainger), replacing it with a baby procured on the black market (1991). Lauren thought it was her baby and named him Dylan Lawrence.
Held Lauren and her own mother, Molly Carter, hostage (1992).
Attempted murder of Lauren and Molly, her mother by setting her mother's house on fire with them inside (1992).
Faked her death (1992).
"Accidental" murder of Dr. Jay Garvin, her shrink (1992?).
Blackmailed Lauren and Brad Carlton (1993). She took photos of their trysts to blackmail them with the photos.
Confessed to James Warwick that she had an abusive childhood and murdered her father by poisoning him (1993?).
Tried to poison pregnant Brooke Logan Forrester https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TdWqmurEJgk
Attempted to tamper with Bridget Forrester's paternity test (1993).
Spiked recovering alcoholic, Macy Alexander's drink with liquor (1993).
Attacked Mike Guthrie a security guard that she befriended (1993).
Possible murder of Dr. Tracy Peters (1993?).
Attempted to kill James Warwick with a fire poker (1994).
Held James hostage (1995).
Nearly drowned Lauren in a hot tub (1995).
Held Eric Forrester, Stephanie Douglas, Brooke Logan, Ridge Forrester, Lauren and James at gunpoint at the Forrester Mansion. (1995).
Poisoned Stephanie and framed Maggie Forrester (1996).
Slapped Amber Moore (Sep 17, 1997).
Got into a cat fight with Maggie Forrestor [Sep 22, 1997]
Nearly drowned Stephanie, then shot her (1998).
Threatened Judy Johnson, Rick Forrester's nanny, into leaving and caused an accident which left Judy a paraplegic (1998?).
Assaulted and slapped Lauren (multiple times).
Unleashed bees on Lance, killing him (2002). Prior, she paid him to drug and rape Amber Moore.
Trespassed on Ridge Forrester and Taylor Hayes's property. (2002)
Plotted to kill Amber (2002). She kidnapped and tortured her.
Trespassed on Eric Forrester's property. (2002)
Held a gun on Eric and Taylor Hamilton, shooting Brooke and Taylor (Oct 16, 2002).
Kidnapped Ridge, Nick Marone and Brooke (2003). She engaged in a fight with Brooke.
Escaped from prison and went to Genoa City (2005?).
Drugged Sugar and forced her to undergo plastic surgery (2005).
Poisoned Lauren and tried to force her jump off a building, then tried to kill her in a boat explosion (2005).
Killed the doctor who performed plastic surgery that made her look like Phyllis Summers.
Strangled Maggie Sullivan.
Locked Paul Williams and Maggie Sullivan in a cage.
Shot Maggie Sullivan.
Kidnapped Phyllis Summers, Summer Newman, and Fenmore Baldwin.
Impersonated Phyllis Summers.
Faked her death again (2007; revealed in 2017 on B&B).
Trespassed on Katie Logan's property (June 2017).
Broke a restraining order set by Eric (June 2017).
Blackmailed Charlie Webber and threatened his life (July 2017).
Kissed a married Eric (August 2017).
Slapped, choked, and attacked Quinn Fuller with a fire poker, and tried to suffocate her also (August 2017).
Blackmailed James Warwick into letting her stay with Eric at the Forrester Mansion (August 2017).
Convinced Mateo to seduce Quinn (October 2017).
Blackmailed Jack Finnegan (August 2021-November 2021).
Trespassed on Steffy Forrester's property (multiple times since August 2021)
Fake collapsed after Finn Finnegan said he wanted her out of his and Hayes Finnegan's lives (September 2021).
Lied to Finn Finnegan that she is dating Deacon Sharpe to get a reaction from him. (2021)
Lied to Finn Finnegan that she doesn't know who his father is.
Exchanged Brooke's non alcoholic champagne with an alcoholic one so Brooke can revert to alcoholism as a revenge for Brooke vowing to protect Steffy Forrester and her family from her. ( December 2021)
Trespassed on Brooke Logan's property. (2022)
Convinced Thomas Forrester to keep her secret about spiking Brooke Logan Forrester's drink to himself so she could have her revenge and Thomas could have his parents reunited (2022)
Threatened Steffy, to not come in between her and her son, Finn and her grandson, Hayes (March 31, 2022 and April 1, 2022)
Shot her son, Finn Finnegan when he jumped in front of Steffy, trying to protect her from Sheila who was pointing a gun at her. (April 1, 2022)
Shot Steffy Forrester and left her and her son, Finn for dead. (April 4, 2022)
Lying that she didn't know about Finn and Steffy being shot. (April 5, 2022)
Attempted to kill Steffy Forrester in the hospital two times, but was interrupted. (April 2022)
Escaped from prison again. (June 2022)
Attacked Li Finnegan. (June 22, 2022)
Thinks she killed Li Finnegan. but is found to be alive by Bill Spencer (June 22, 2022-July 22, 2022)
Held Finn hostage (June 22-July 22, 2022)
Injected Finn with a syringe a few times since June, trying to save his life and then trying to stop him from leaving in July (2022)
Manipulated Deacon Sharpe to sleep with her by using false identity and a wig along with a skin mask. (August 2022)
Secretly trespassed by going to Steffy and Finn's property and held her grandson Hayes Finnegan while Finn was on the phone in the other room (September 2022)
Stole few bottles of whisky and steaks from il giardino. (October 2022)
Stole a vehicle (December 2022)
Engaged police officers in a high-speed chase (December 2022)
Broke into Steffy and Finn's home (December 2022)
Admitted to Deacon Sharpe that she's using Bill Spencer Jr. to keep her freedom (March 2023)
Secretly kissed and had sex with Deacon Sharpe while being in a relationship with Bill Spencer Jr. (March 2023)
Broke into Steffy and Finn’s home once again (February 2024)
Attempted murder of Steffy upon break-in, resulting in her own stabbing death via self-defense (February 2024)
Faked her death for a third time (April 2024)

Maladies and Injuries[]

Gave birth to daughter, Mary Warwick (June 6, 1987).
Gave birth to twins a son and daughter, Ryan Callahan and Daisy Carter (May 25, 1988).
Gave birth to a stillborn son, Baby Boy Grainger (1991 revised to 1988).
Choked by Stephanie Douglas (1996).
Choked by Ridge Forrester (1998).
Was attacked by Taylor Hamilton and Brooke Logan in a gun struggle (2002).
Was choked again by Ridge (2002).
Was attacked by Brooke (2003).
Gave birth to a daughter Diana Carter (2003).
Shot and presumed killed by Lauren Fenmore in self-defense (2007).
Wrongly convicted of the attempted murder of Quinn Fuller (June 2017).
Shot by Steffy Forrester (July 2017).
Hit over the head with a vase thrown by Quinn, causing a contused head wound (August 2017).
Slapped by Steffy Forrester (multiple times since August 2021).
Strangled by Finn Finnegan (July 2022)
Cut off her own toe in order to leave DNA when faking her death. (August 2022)
Fell from the balcony at Bill Spencer Jr.'s house while trying to get away from him (March 2023)
Had a heart attack (March 2023)
Punched in the face by Steffy after shoving her. (February 2024)
Stabbed in self-defense by Steffy Forrester Finnegan after breaking and entering with intent to murder her but it wasn't Sheila. (February and April 2024)